“I'm kind of like, Am I getting scammed right now?” thought Rebecca, who wants her identity kept private. They flirted for a while, he flattered her, and she wrote, “I’d do anything to see you get off.” Billy replied with a blurry nude picture of himself, unlockable for $3. Rebecca tagged Billy and soon he slid into her DMs. Then one day Billy asked his followers to tag their crush. She was a fan of the 31-year-old dark-haired, boyish comedian and podcast host from Brooklyn, and his OnlyFans account was free to join. When Rebecca, a 28-year-old who lives in Arizona, started following Billy on OnlyFans, she didn’t think much of it.